Fullmetal Alchemist Commits Where Other Manga Don't

Warning: this piece could have HUGE spoilers for the ending of Fullmetal Alchemist! You probably have not but learn this in style sequence, be warned.

Fullmetal Alchemist was my introduction to Japanese comics, and I adored it. I cherished its gothic sensibilities — the reanimated useless, mad science, and bonds solid via guilt. I wished to be like Edward Elric, although looking back Alphonse was the very best. Because the sequence continued, although, what most overwhelmed me was its sense of scale. If the 2003 anime saved its give attention to the Elric household and its hangers-on, the manga expands to a daft conspiracy plot overlaying centuries of historical past and numerous casualties. The villain’s final weapon isn’t simply alchemy, however one thing worse — Amestris, Ed, and Al’s residence nation.


I’ve saved Fullmetal Alchemist near my coronary heart because the years have passed by, whilst I’ve come to like different manga and anime simply as a lot if no more. Nevertheless it’s solely up to now few years that I’ve began pondering in earnest, as an grownup, about what the sequence was actually about. Fullmetal Alchemist sticks to the well-worn themes of friendship, wrestle, and victory. Edward and Alphonse overcome their tough background to excel at their chosen passion and turn into the very best on the planet, like different shounen heroes did earlier than them and others would afterward. If it’s in a darker tonal register than another Shounen Bounce titles (wait a minute, Ed’s rival is an older man and a struggle prison??) the distinction is made up by unhealthy jokes about Ed’s top. However Fullmetal Alchemist isn’t only a story about coaching with your mates to turn into the best. It’s additionally about overthrowing the state, and that’s the place the story begins cooking for me.

Fullmetal Alchemist

Picture through VIZ


There are many shounen comics and anime that play with anti-authoritarianism. Japanese media is awash with absent or disappointing fathers, boastful superiors, and unfair techniques. Naruto and his mates grapple with abandonment and familial betrayal. The hero society of My Hero Academia has its share of overbearing mother and father, and even well-intentioned academics like All May are made to resist previous errors. Ushio’s dad is annoying.

However the arc of shounen comics bends towards the established order. Naruto and Sasuke come to appreciate that their households cherished them in spite of everything, or at the very least had good intentions behind their cruelty. All May is certainly an excellent man, and even antagonists like Endeavor are given a second probability. Ushio’s dad’s incompetence was an act placed on to guard his son. And so forth. After all, in our world, many children undergo a part the place they dislike their mother and father or attempt to run away from residence. As time goes by they understand their mother and father’ perspective, and are available to grasp them just a little extra. However some mother and father are abusive, and a few techniques are irredeemably merciless. Exterior of One Piece (the place every arc climaxes with Luffy punching the villain via bigger and bigger authorities buildings) the benevolence of authority is usually taken without any consideration in shounen comics. Any hurt inflicted isn’t the norm, however an unlucky mistake.


Against this, as Fullmetal Alchemist continues it turns into clear that there’s nothing regular about Amestris. It’s a state dedicated to wiping out surrounding nations in order that its secret ruler can discount away the lives of its folks in alternate for godhood. We come to like a lot of these folks, however the state itself has no different operate. Its alchemy magic, helpful in a pinch, is totally within the arms of the nation’s rulers. The thinker’s stones that gasoline the best acts of alchemy are powered by human lives. Amestris is loss of life. It’s a nation that has dedicated genocide. It can’t be redeemed. It have to be destroyed.

Fullmetal Alchemist

Picture through VIZ


Fullmetal Alchemist is a narrative about overthrowing Amestris. Edward and Alphonse come to appreciate, together with their mates, that it’s the accountability of these born throughout the nation’s borders to destroy it. Roy Mustang and his compatriots, who’ve killed many individuals within the service of their nation, determine that the one ethical factor to do is to steer a revolt towards their boss. Hohenheim — Ed and Al’s absentee father — abandons his household as a result of he realizes that the one option to liberate Amestris from its grasp’s management is to discover a totally different set of instruments. Via their collective efforts, they finish the reign of a authorities whose cause for being is countless conquest and torture.


After all, Fullmetal Alchemist is a narrative for kids. You can’t undo years of imperialism by punching an historic synthetic demigod within the face. You can’t substitute a merciless ruler for a only one, maintain the engine of the state intact and anticipate {that a} nation will magically redeem itself within the eyes of its neighbors. Fullmetal Alchemist doesn’t try to grapple with the query of whether or not its heroes, who regardless of their previous sins are seen within the present-day as basically good,  have been fatally compromised by their time working the gears of a loss of life state. No, on the finish of the sequence Roy turns into Fuhrer and every little thing is ok. Amestris isn’t rebuilt, however reformed. At present in 2020, understanding what I do now, I don’t suppose that’s sufficient.


Nonetheless, Fullmetal Alchemist is a narrative for kids, and that’s the reason it’s helpful. It set me on the street to Revolutionary Woman Utena and its fairy story world of cruelty. Fullmetal Alchemist taught me to not take the phrases of adults without any consideration. In as we speak’s world, the place we’re extra conscious than ever of our accountability to others, I’m reminded of Jason Thompson’s previous evaluate of Fullmetal Alchemist, written as a part of his Home of “1000 Manga” columns on Anime Information Community. That each Amestris and America start with the letter A.


What do you consider Fullmetal Alchemist? Did you develop up with the manga and the 2003 anime, like I did, or the Brotherhood remake some years later? Is “Once more” a greater or worse track than “Rewrite?” Tell us within the feedback!

Try Premium for Free!


Adam W is a Options Author at Crunchyroll. When he is not rereading Hiromu Arakawa’s omake comics on the finish of every Fullmetal Alchemist quantity, he sporadically contributes with a free coalition of mates to a weblog known as Is not It Electrifying? You may comply with him on Twitter at: @wendeego 


Do you’re keen on writing? Do you’re keen on anime? You probably have an thought for a options story, pitch it to Crunchyroll Options!